The titles of the posts that evaluate chapter 6 provide a glimpse of some of its theoretical shortcomings.
- Misrepresenting Hasan And Confusing Strata And Metafunctions
- Misrepresenting Inconsistency As Consistency
- Misconstruing Collocation And Interstratal Relations
- Misconstruing Substitution–&–Ellipsis
- Misrepresenting Halliday & Hasan
- Misconstruing Stratification And Grammatical Metaphor
- Resorting To A Misconstrual of Stratification
- Misconstruing Cataphoric Reference
- Misconstruing Stratification
- Misconstruing Textual Grammar As "Redounding With" Interpersonal And Experiential Semantics
- Misrepresenting Halliday & Hasan And Confusing Metafunctions
- Misrepresenting Interstratal Realisation, Grammatical Metaphor & Register
- Misconstruing Strata And Metafunctions As Modules
- Misrepresenting Realisation And Preselection
- Misunderstanding Stratification
- Blurring The Distinction Between Realisation And Instantiation
- Misrepresenting Intrastratal Studies As Interstratal
- Misrepresenting Grammatical Metaphor
- Misrepresenting Halliday On The Stratification Of Content
- Misunderstanding The Principles Of Metafunction And Stratification
- Misunderstanding The Textual Metafunction And Misrepresenting Context As Register
- Misrepresenting Tenor As A 'Register Variable'
- Misrepresenting The Grammatical Realisation Of Discourse Semantic Ideation
- Misrepresenting The Grammatical Realisation Of Discourse Semantic Identification
- Misrepresenting The Grammatical Realisation Of Discourse Semantic Conjunction
- Ideational Metaphor And Mode
- Misconstruing Non-Structural Cohesion As Discourse Structure
- Misconstruing Types Of Language As More Abstract Than Language
- Misconstruing Contextual Systems And 'Text Forming Resources'
- Misrepresenting Grammatical Metaphor
- Taking A Monostratal Approach To Grammatical Metaphor
- Mistaking Ideational Metaphor For Metaphor
- Misrepresenting Ideational Metaphor
- Claiming That Location Circumstances Realise Relations Between Clauses
- Misrepresenting Ideational Metaphor As An Interaction Of Logical & Experiential Metaphors
- Reducing Expansion To Conjunctive Relations
- Misconstruing Ideational Metaphor
- Misrepresenting Internal Conjunctive Relations
- Misconstruing Experiential Manifestations Of Expansion As Logical Metaphor
- Under-Representing The Scope Of Ideational Metaphor
- Misconstruing Technical Terms As Grammatical Metaphors
- Reducing Ideational Metaphor To The Transcategorisation Of Elements
- Confusing Logogenesis With Text Analysis & Misrepresenting The Unpacking Of Metaphor
- Misrepresenting The Unpacking Of Metaphor
- Misconstruing Modal Adjuncts As Interpersonal Metaphor
- Misconstruing Congruent Obligation As Metaphorical Inclination
- Misconstruing Metaphors Of Mood
- Misrepresenting Metaphors Of Mood
- On The Ineffability Of Interpersonal Texturing
- Misrepresenting (The Unpacking Of) Interpersonal Metaphor
- Confusing Metalanguage And Language
- Misunderstanding (The Unpacking Of) Interpersonal Metaphor
- Problems With The Argument For "Textual" Metaphor
- The Confused Notion Of "Logically Oriented Textual Metaphor"
- The Confused Notion Of "Interpersonally Oriented Textual Metaphor"
- Misunderstanding The Trinocular Perspective And Misconstruing Context As Register
- Confusing Text Type With Text Structure And Misrepresenting Hasan's Work On Cohesive Harmony
- Misrepresenting Hasan's Work On Cohesion
- “One Apparently Unresolved Problem With Hasan's Technique”
- Misconstruing Enhancement As Elaboration And Misidentifying Metaphor
- The Problem Of Overlapping Lexical Strings And Reference Chains
- Misrepresenting Hasan's Cohesive Harmony
- Presenting Misunderstandings Of Hasan's Cohesive Harmony As Deficiencies In The Model
- Misrepresenting Hasan's Work On Coherence As Formalist
- Misrepresenting Information Structure
- The Origin Of 'Method Of Development': Peter Fries
- Misconstruing Marked Topical Theme
- Adjusting The Data To Fit The Theory
- Misunderstanding Internal Conjunction
- Problems With The Argument For Hyper-Theme
- Misconstruing A Graphological Unit As Semantic
- Intuiting Others' Assessments of Coherence
- Falsifying Data: Misrepresenting An Interview Transcript As A Writing Exercise
- Questions “Predicting” Answers
- Locating Graphological Units 'Above' A Grammatical Unit
- Confusing Writing Pedagogy With Linguistic Theory
- Misrepresenting Halliday On 'Theme'
- Assigning A Text To The Wrong “Genre” (Register)
- A False Conclusion Invalidly Argued From False Premises
- Misconstruing Theme Selection As An Interpersonal Resource
- Misconstruing Stratification, Metafunction And Metaphor
- Confusing The Textual And Interpersonal Metafunctions
- Misrepresenting Phonology
- Misrepresenting Textual Analysis
- Misinterpreting Theme And New
- Failing To Model (Or Notice) The Interplay Of New And (Marked) Theme
- Not Accounting For A Distinctive Mode Of Development
- Misrepresenting New Information
- Problems With The Complementarity Of Hyper-Theme & Hyper-New
- Misidentifying New Information
- When New Information Isn't — But Repeated Information Is
- Confusing Textual Phase With Textual Status
- Confusing Writing Pedagogy With Linguistic Theory
- Presenting Prescription As Theoretical Description
- When An Abstract Is A Summary And A Summary Is An Introduction
- Misconstruing A Grammatical Reference Item As An Accumulation Of New Information
- Not Understanding Interstratal Realisation
- Misconstruing Modal Responsibility (Semiotic Order) As Social Responsibility (Material Order)
- Misconstruing Subject And Theme
- Confusing Metafunctions And Axes
- Misconstruing Modal Responsibility In Terms Of Exchange Resolution
- Confusing Subject With Validity
- Misunderstanding The Metafunctions
- Blurring Metafunctions
- Misconstruing Semiotic Validity As Social Success
- Confusing Metafunctions, Misunderstanding Modal Responsibility And Misinterpreting Data
- The Argument That "Verbal Processes Are Fundamentally Metaphorical In Nature"
- Using Embedding To Argue About Hypotaxis
- Misconstruing Modal Responsibility As Speaker At Risk
- Using A Middle Clause To Illustrate Agency
- Misconstruing Strata As Modules
- A Short Summary Of Some Of The Misunderstandings Of Chapter 6
- Misrepresenting Cohesive Harmony
- Rhapsodising On Method Of Development
- Rhapsodising On Point
- Rhapsodising On The Complementarity Of Method Of Development And Point
- Rhapsodising On Modal Responsibility
- Using Allegory To Misrepresent The Rôle Of Mood And Residue In Modal Responsibility
- Rhapsodising On Grammatical Metaphor
- Misrepresenting Grammatical Metaphor
- Using Metaphor To Misrepresent Grammatical Metaphor
- Under-Acknowledging A Significant Intellectual Source
No comments:
Post a Comment