The titles of the posts that evaluate chapter 5 provide a glimpse of some of its theoretical shortcomings.
- Misrepresenting The Chapter 4 Model Of Conjunction
- Misconstruing Context As Register
- Not Recognising The Stratification Of Content: Dictionary Definitions
- Not Recognising The Stratification Of Content: Thesaurus
- Misrepresenting The Model Of Transitivity
- Misconstruing Unassigned vs Assigned As Single vs Double Agency
- Misrepresenting 'Semiotic'
- Misrepresenting The Directions Of Coding And Mistaking A Verbal Projection Nexus For An Identifying Clause
- Falsely Claiming To Have Uniquely Classified Two Lexical Items
- Misconstruing The Agency Of Identifying Clauses
- Lexical Cohesion Update
- Confusing Textual Cohesion With Experiential Delicacy
- Relocating Lexis Outside Language
- Misconstruing Semantics As Context
- Inconsistencies Of Structure And Metafunction
- Misconstruing The Difference Between Lexical Item And Grammatical Word
- Confusing Register (Language) With Context (Culture)
- Confusing Context With Semantics
- Misconstruing First Order Field As Its Semantic Description [1]
- Misconstruing First Order Field As Its Semantic Description [2]
- Misconstruing Experiential As Constituent Of Logical
- Misconstruing Stratification: Semantics Realising Semantics
- Misrepresenting Congruent Vs Incongruent
- Confusing Context, Semantics And Lexicogrammar
- Misrepresenting Superordination (Hyponymy)
- Misconstruing Field As Language
- Misconstruing Meronymy As Hyponymy
- Misconstruing Ellipsis Of Repetition As Relational Hyp(er)onymy
- Misconstruing Synonymy
- Confusing Lexis With Grammar
- Misconstruing Antonymy
- Misconstruing Ellipsis Of Repetition As Relational Meronymy [1]
- Misconstruing Ellipsis Of Repetition As Relational Meronymy [2]
- Misconstruing Location (Enhancement) As Possession (Extension)
- Misconstruing Ellipsis Of Repetition As Relational Meronymy [3]
- Misconstruing Synonymy + Collocation As Relational Meronymy
- Confusing Lexical Cohesion And Reference
- Misrepresenting Hyponymy As Bridging Hyponymy
- Misrepresenting Meronymy As Bridging Meronymy
- An Unwarranted Claim About the System Of Identification
- Misconstruing Ranges As Mediums
- Confusing Collocation With Transitivity
- Misconstruing Logico-Semantic Relations Realised In The Clause [1]
- Misconstruing Logico-Semantic Relations Realised In The Clause [2]
- Misconstruing Expansion Relations Realised In The Nominal Group
- Misrepresenting Ranges As Mediums
- Misconstruing Enhancing Circumstances As Elaborating Ranges
- Misconstruing Enhancement (Cause) As Elaboration
- Misconstruing Extension (Composition) As Elaboration
- Misconstruing Extension (Possession) As Elaboration
- Misconstruing Elaboration As Enhancement
- Misrepresenting Elaboration
- Misconstruing Enhancement & Projection As Extension
- Misconstruing Elaboration As Extension
- Reducing All Verbal Group Complex Relations To Extension
- Relocating A Subset Of Manner Circumstances To The Verbal Group
- Reclassifying Function According To Form
- Misconstruing Projection As Enhancement
- Misconstruing Enhancement As Elaboration And Elaboration As Extension
- Classifying Expansion Type On The Basis Of Form
- Presenting Theoretical Misunderstandings As An 'Alternative Perspective'
- Misconstruing Experiential Nuclearity As Logical Expansion Type
- Misunderstanding 'Instantiate'
- Misconstruing Elaboration As Extension And Extension As Elaboration
- Misconstruing Logical Relations As Interpersonal Enactments
- Confusing Metafunctions And Confusing Context With Semantics
- Misconstruing Extension As Enhancement
- Confusing Implication, Cause And Modulation
- Misconstruing Ideational Semantics As Field
- Confusing Strata And Confusing Metafunctions
- Self-Contradiction And Misunderstanding Stratification
- No Identifiable Discourse Semantic Unit Realised By Clause Complexes
- The Avoidance Of Experiential Meaning In Discourse Semantics
- Using Ideational Labels For Textual Units And Vice Versa
- Misconstruing Incongruent Realisations And Expansion Types
- Misconstruing Extension As Elaboration And General As Instantial
- Misconstruing General Lexical Cohesion As Instantial
- Confusing Strata And Confusing Metafunctions
- Claiming The Verb 'Stand' Is A Repetition Of The Verb 'Tabled'
- Claiming That Analysing A Text Can Alter The Mode Of The Text
- Structural & Metafunctional Inconsistencies
- Misconstruing Extension As Elaboration
- Misconstruing General Lexical Cohesion As Instantial
- Misconstruing Mode As Genre
- Misrepresenting Processes As Subclasses Of Clause
- Misconstruing Enhancement (And Complementarity) As Extension
- Misconstruing Mode As Genre
- Misconstruing Context As Register
- Misidentifying The Main Differences Between Martin And Hasan
- Misrepresenting Grammatical Metaphor & Neglecting Interstratal Accountability
- Misidentifying Transitivity Rôles And Expansion Types
- A Summary Of Discourse Systems Inconsistencies
- Misconstruing Instantial Probabilities As Structural Relations
- Construing A Scale From Hyponym To Ellipsis (Via Word Classes)
- A Convoluted Non-Sequitur
- Misconstruing Instantiation Probability As The Opposite Of Anaphoric Reference
- Three Minor Clarifications
- Confusing Three Distinct Notions Of "Predicting" Discourse
- Claiming That Conjunctive Relations Are Realised By Nouns
- Multiplying A Misunderstanding Of The External Vs Internal Distinction
- Misrepresenting Field And Misconstruing Interstratal Realisation
- Misconstruing 'A Realises B' As 'A Makes B Material'
- Misconstruing 'A Realises B' As 'A Makes B Come To Be'
- Misconstruing 'A Realises B' As 'A Reconstitutes B'
- Misconstruing 'A Realises B' As 'A Is A Metaphor For B'
- Self-Contradiction
- Misrepresenting Interstratal Relations
No comments:
Post a Comment